Audit Technology Costs for US Retirement Budgets

You map out Medicare premiums with extreme precision. You calculate property tax increases down to the decimal point and argue with your insurance broker about umbrella policy limits. You hold a spreadsheet detailing exactly how much a trip to Italy will cost in 2028. Yet, somewhere sitting on your kitchen island right now is a rectangle of glass and lithium-ion battery cells that will quietly extract twelve hundred dollars from your bank account every three years. You completely ignore the financial decay of your own electronics.

Technology spending operates as a stealth tax on a fixed income. A retired actuary living in Des Moines might budget carefully for home maintenance, setting aside three thousand dollars annually for roof repairs and HVAC service. That same actuary will walk into an Apple Store on a Tuesday morning because his iPad battery stopped holding a charge and casually swipe a credit card for nine hundred dollars without classifying it as a capital expense. Hardware dies. Software expires. Subscription models multiply like weeds in a spring garden. Failing to audit the constant, predictable destruction of your personal technology creates a permanent leak in your retirement cash flow.


The Hidden Financial Drain of Tech Obsolescence

Consumer electronics companies hate the idea of a satisfied customer. A satisfied customer holding a perfectly functional five-year-old iPhone generates absolutely zero revenue for shareholders. Manufacturers engineer products to decay gracefully, pushing you psychologically and physically toward a new purchase long before the device actually fails. They construct glass sandwiches that shatter easily, solder memory directly to motherboards so you cannot upgrade them, and seal batteries behind industrial adhesive to discourage simple replacements.

You are participating in a forced subscription model where the hardware acts as the monthly fee. Averaged over a lifetime, the cost of keeping a smartphone in your pocket currently exceeds twenty-six thousand dollars. That figure covers the phone, the case, the wall charger, and the occasional cracked screen repair. If you are sixty-five years old and expect to live to ninety, you are looking at twenty-five years of mandatory hardware cycles. Assuming average pricing, you will spend at least ten thousand dollars strictly on mobile phones before you die. Adding a laptop, a tablet, and a smart television pushes your hardware liability past twenty-five thousand dollars. These are not rounding errors in a retirement portfolio.


Why Fixed Incomes Hate Hardware Cycles

During your working years, a sudden thousand-dollar laptop replacement is annoying. You absorb the cost with your next paycheck or defer a bonus. In retirement, a sudden thousand-dollar expense forces you to sell assets. If the stock market is down fifteen percent in October and your primary desktop computer suffers a catastrophic motherboard failure, you have to sell depreciated index funds simply to buy a machine to check your email and manage your Vanguard account. You lock in a stock market loss to replace a depreciating asset. This double penalty destroys capital.

A fixed income demands predictability. Hardware failure is notoriously unpredictable, but the lifecycle of the technology is entirely knowable. A lithium-ion battery degrades noticeably after five hundred charge cycles. Solid-state drives write a finite amount of data before the flash memory degrades. Recognizing these physical limitations allows you to predict exactly when the expense will hit.


The Software Update Death Sentence

Your hardware might survive for eight years, but the software controlling it will artificially execute the device long before the processor dies. Apple, Google, and Microsoft control the lifelines. When a manufacturer declares a device "vintage" or "obsolete," they stop writing code for it. Your screen remains bright. Your keyboard works perfectly. The machine simply refuses to connect securely to the modern internet.


Forced Hardware Upgrades via Operating Systems

Look at the transition to Windows 11. Microsoft implemented strict hardware requirements, specifically demanding a Trusted Platform Module (TPM) 2.0 chip. Millions of fully functional, lightning-fast desktop computers built in 2016 suddenly found themselves on death row. They could not install the new operating system. While Windows 10 continues to receive support until late 2025, anyone holding older hardware must eventually buy a completely new computer simply because the motherboard lacks a specific security chip. The software company forced the hardware upgrade.

Apple employs a similar tactic with iOS. An older iPhone runs perfectly until Apple releases an operating system that requires more random-access memory than the phone possesses. The update installs, and the phone immediately slows to a crawl. Apps take four seconds to open. The keyboard lags behind your typing. You walk into the store convinced your phone is broken. It is not broken. It is suffocating under the weight of bloated software. You buy the new model because the frustration becomes unbearable.


Security Vulnerabilities as a Replacement Driver

You cannot stubbornly use an outdated device. If you manage your retirement accounts through a banking app on an Android phone that stopped receiving security patches in 2023, you are carrying a loaded financial weapon in your pocket. Hackers exploit unpatched vulnerabilities rapidly. A single compromised password or a malicious text message payload can drain a checking account in seconds. Security updates are mandatory for financial survival. When the manufacturer stops patching the device, the device is dead. You must factor the manufacturer's stated support window directly into your replacement budget.


Dissecting the Smartphone Replacement Cycle

The smartphone represents the most highly utilized piece of equipment in human history. A retiree relies on it for two-factor authentication, medical portal access, family communication, and digital photography. The average American replaces their phone every 2.64 years. Following this national average on a fixed income borders on financial negligence.


The True Cost of a Flagship Device

An entry-level iPhone 15 costs roughly eight hundred dollars. The Pro Max version pushes past twelve hundred dollars. Samsung prices its Galaxy S series similarly. The sticker price tells only half the story. The carrier financing models hide the true cost by splitting the payment into thirty-six monthly installments of thirty-three dollars. You do not feel the impact of a twelve-hundred-dollar purchase because it disguises itself as a minor utility bill. You must look at the total contracted price. If you upgrade a flagship phone every three years, you are spending roughly four hundred dollars a year strictly on the privilege of holding a rectangle of glass.


Moving from Two-Year to Five-Year Cycles

The technological leaps between phone generations flattened dramatically around 2020. The difference between an iPhone X and an iPhone 12 was massive. The difference between an iPhone 13 and an iPhone 15 is negligible for anyone not shooting professional video. The processor is slightly faster. The camera performs slightly better in low light. These minor iterative updates do not justify a thousand-dollar expenditure.

You can stretch a smartphone lifecycle to five years easily. Google now promises seven years of operating system updates for its Pixel 8 devices. Apple routinely supports its hardware for six years. By extending your replacement cycle from thirty months to sixty months, you cut your lifetime mobile hardware costs exactly in half. You save thousands of dollars over a retirement timeline without sacrificing any meaningful functionality.


Battery Degradation Versus Motherboard Failure

The primary reason people abandon a three-year-old phone is battery anxiety. The phone drops to twenty percent by two in the afternoon. Instead of fixing the specific problem, they buy a new phone. A lithium-ion battery is a consumable part, exactly like the brake pads on a Honda Civic. You do not buy a new Honda Civic when the brake pads wear out.

An official battery replacement at an Apple Store costs under one hundred dollars. Swapping a degraded battery restores the phone to peak performance immediately because modern operating systems actively throttle processor speed to prevent old batteries from causing random shutdowns. Spending ninety dollars in year three guarantees the phone survives until year five. You trade a ninety-dollar maintenance fee for a massive capital delay.


The Independent Repair Shop Alternative

A cracked screen drives the second largest wave of unnecessary upgrades. A manufacturer will quote three hundred dollars to fix a broken display on an older device, hoping you simply apply that money toward a new purchase. Local repair shops operating out of strip malls charge significantly less. A guy running a repair desk next to a dry cleaner in Sacramento can swap an iPhone screen for ninety dollars using aftermarket parts. The color accuracy might drop by three percent, but the device functions perfectly. Learning to utilize third-party repair services preserves the hardware you already own.


Analyzing Personal Computing Costs

Retirees require a proper computer. A tablet is a consumption device. A computer is a production device. Managing a complex spreadsheet of municipal bond ladders or writing a detailed email to a tax accountant on a six-inch glass screen is an exercise in misery. Choosing the right computing form factor drastically alters your required replacement timeline.


The Desktop PC Versus the Laptop Compromise

Laptops dominate sales because people value portability. You want to sit on the couch and read the news. Portability carries a severe mechanical penalty. A laptop crams high-heat components into a chassis thinner than a paperback book. Heat destroys silicon. Heat destroys batteries. The average lifespan of a consumer laptop hovers around 5.85 years. They fail constantly. Keyboards break. Hinges snap. The battery eventually swells and warps the trackpad.

A desktop computer sitting quietly under a desk operates in a completely different physical reality. It possesses massive cooling fans. It pulls power directly from the wall, bypassing the entire battery degradation cycle. If a component fails inside a desktop, you open the metal side panel and replace the exact piece that died. A power supply costs sixty dollars. A new stick of RAM costs forty dollars. You can keep a high-quality desktop running for ten to twelve years with minor fifty-dollar interventions.


Thermal Throttling in Aging Laptops

Dust is the enemy of the laptop. Over three years, the microscopic cooling fins inside a MacBook or a Dell XPS clog with pet hair and household dust. The cooling fan spins faster, generating noise, but fails to push air out of the chassis. The processor hits ninety degrees Celsius and immediately throttles its speed to prevent a fire. The computer feels incredibly slow. Most consumers assume the computer is obsolete. A computer technician armed with a tiny screwdriver and a can of compressed air can clear the blockage in ten minutes, instantly restoring the original speed. Auditing your tech costs requires understanding basic maintenance.


Why Desktops Win the Longevity Game

If you rarely take your computer out of the house, buying a laptop is a financial error. You are paying a massive premium for miniaturized components that will break faster and cost more to replace. An eight-hundred-dollar desktop PC provides twice the computing power of an eight-hundred-dollar laptop and will easily outlive it by half a decade. Pair the desktop with a high-quality twenty-seven-inch monitor. The monitor will last fifteen years. You separate the screen from the computing core, allowing you to replace the cheap box on the floor when it finally dies without throwing away a perfectly good display.


Tablet Computers as Secondary Screen Expenses

Tablets sit in a bizarre financial purgatory. They cost almost as much as a laptop but offer the limited functionality of a smartphone. A base model iPad runs roughly four hundred dollars. Consumers replace them every 4.7 years. If you already own a smartphone and a desktop, the tablet represents a pure luxury expense. It is a four-hundred-dollar magazine replacement. If you audit your technology budget and find a ballooning deficit, the tablet is the first device you cut. A retired teacher in Boise does not need a twelve-hundred-dollar iPad Pro to watch Netflix in bed. The phone works fine. The television works better.


The Financial Black Hole of the Smart Home

Ten years ago, a home technology budget consisted of a television and a cable box. Today, a standard suburban home contains twenty IP addresses. Refrigerators request Wi-Fi passwords. Doorbells stream high-definition video to cloud servers. Lightbulbs contain microprocessors. The smart home industry successfully convinced consumers to replace reliable analog hardware with fragile digital hardware.


Voice Assistants and Hub Hardware Decay

You buy an Amazon Echo or a Google Nest Hub for fifty dollars. You place it on the kitchen counter. It sets timers and plays music. These devices are loss leaders for massive data companies. They sell the hardware cheaply to lock you into their ecosystem. Three years later, the microphone degrades. The software becomes sluggish. The company releases a new model with a slightly better speaker and stops updating the old one. Fifty dollars every three years seems trivial, but when you scatter six of these devices across a house, you create a three-hundred-dollar recurring replacement cycle for clocks that talk.


Security Cameras and Subscription Traps

A smart security system operates as a financial trap. You buy a Ring doorbell for two hundred dollars. You buy three exterior battery-powered cameras for four hundred dollars. You assume the purchase is complete. Then the application informs you that to actually save the video of the delivery driver dropping off a package, you must pay a monthly subscription fee.


The True Cost of Cloud Storage Fees

Ring charges forty dollars a year for a single camera or a hundred dollars a year to cover the whole house. Google Nest prices its Aware subscription similarly. You are suddenly paying a hundred dollars annually strictly for cloud video storage. Over a twenty-year retirement, that equals two thousand dollars just to record footage of stray cats walking across your driveway. If you cancel the subscription, the hardware becomes practically useless, offering only live viewing. You must audit these specific recurring costs immediately. They drain cash silently.


Hardwiring Versus Battery Operated Systems

Battery-powered cameras die. The lithium-ion cells exposed to freezing winters and brutal summers degrade rapidly. After four years, a camera that used to hold a charge for six months requires charging every three weeks. You throw the camera away and buy a new one. To break this cycle, you must install hardwired Power over Ethernet (PoE) camera systems. You run a physical copper wire through the attic to the camera. The data stores locally on a hard drive inside your house. You pay zero monthly subscription fees. The cameras require no batteries. The initial installation labor costs a thousand dollars, but the system runs flawlessly for a decade with zero ongoing operational costs. You trade a permanent subscription liability for a single capital expense.


Smart Thermostats and Automated Appliance Lifespans

A traditional analog Honeywell thermostat lasts thirty years. It contains a mercury switch and a coil of wire. It never breaks. A smart thermostat contains a color touchscreen, a Wi-Fi radio, and complex software. It costs two hundred and fifty dollars and will likely fail within eight years. The energy savings generated by the smart schedule rarely offset the replacement cost of the hardware itself. The appliance industry follows the same destructive path. A washing machine with a touchscreen dial will fail because the touchscreen shorts out long before the actual drum motor dies. When auditing a retirement budget, strip out all "smart" appliances. Buy heavy, dumb machines with physical buttons. Let the computer industry make computers. Let the appliance industry make appliances. Mixing the two creates a massive financial vulnerability.


Building a Tech Replacement Sinking Fund

You cannot react to hardware failures emotionally. If your television screen turns black on a Thursday, you should already know exactly which account holds the cash to replace it. Corporate accounting departments use depreciation schedules to plan for equipment replacement. You must apply this exact corporate logic to your personal balance sheet through a sinking fund.


Calculating Your Annual Hardware Burn Rate

Sit down at the kitchen table and write down every piece of technology you currently own. Next to each item, list the current replacement cost and the expected lifespan. The math is simple division.

Phone: $1,000 / 5 years = $200 per year.

Laptop: $1,200 / 6 years = $200 per year.

Television: $800 / 8 years = $100 per year.

Tablet: $500 / 5 years = $100 per year.

Router and Modem: $300 / 5 years = $60 per year.

In this basic example, your annual hardware burn rate is six hundred and sixty dollars. This means your technology is physically deteriorating at a rate of fifty-five dollars a month. If you are not saving fifty-five dollars a month explicitly for technology, you are running a financial deficit.


Structuring the Replacement Schedule

You cannot simply throw six hundred dollars into a checking account and hope the timing works out. Hardware failures tend to cluster. You might buy a phone, a laptop, and a router in the same calendar year. This creates a massive cash flow spike that a fixed income cannot absorb safely.


Staggering Major Purchases to Avoid Cash Flow Spikes

Force your upgrades onto a staggered timeline. If your phone and laptop both reach year five simultaneously, do not replace them in the same month. Replace the phone in October. Wait until the following May to replace the laptop. Purposely delay upgrades to smooth out the capital expenditure. If you stagger the purchases effectively, you only ever buy one major piece of hardware per calendar year. This keeps your annual cash outflow highly predictable.


Designating a Specific Savings Yield for Tech

Open a high-yield savings account entirely separate from your primary checking account. Name the account "Hardware Depreciation." Set up an automated transfer of your monthly burn rate amount. If your calculated burn rate is fifty-five dollars a month, that exact amount moves automatically on the first of the month. When the laptop dies, you pull the twelve hundred dollars from this specific account. You never touch your core emergency fund. You never sell equities. You never put the purchase on a high-interest credit card. You self-fund your technology habit cleanly.


Negotiating the Software Subscription Tax

Hardware is a visible cost. Software is an invisible parasite. In 2012, you drove to an electronics store, bought a physical disc containing Microsoft Office for one hundred and fifty dollars, and used it for a decade. The software industry realized they were leaving massive amounts of money on the table. They murdered the perpetual license.


Shifting from Perpetual Licenses to Monthly Fees

Software exists entirely as a service now. Adobe Photoshop costs twenty dollars a month. Microsoft 365 costs seventy dollars a year. You rent the code. If you stop paying, the software stops working immediately. You lose access to your own files. For a retiree trying to control fixed expenses, this model is catastrophic. You are signing up for an infinite stream of future liabilities.


Microsoft Office, Cloud Storage, and Entertainment

You must perform a ruthless audit of your credit card statements. Look for recurring charges. The average consumer dramatically underestimates their monthly subscription spending. Apple charges three dollars a month for iCloud storage. Google charges two dollars a month for Google One. Microsoft charges seven dollars. These small, single-digit charges escape notice. You justify them easily. "It is just the price of a cup of coffee." Five different cloud subscriptions equal two hundred dollars a year. You are bleeding cash to store digital photographs of your garden.


Streaming Fatigue and Cost Containment

Entertainment subscriptions behave exactly like software licenses. Netflix, Hulu, Disney+, Amazon Prime, and Max. The streaming revolution promised to save consumers from the hundred-dollar cable bill. Now, consumers simply pay one hundred and twenty dollars to six different streaming companies. A retiree on a fixed budget cannot maintain five overlapping video services.

Implement the rotation strategy. You only need one streaming service active at any given moment. Pay for Netflix in January. Watch all the specific shows you want. Cancel Netflix on January 30th. Subscribe to HBO in February. Watch their specific catalog. Cancel it in March. The services make canceling incredibly easy with a single button click on a website. By rotating one service at a time, you cut your annual entertainment software bill by eighty percent while consuming the exact same amount of premium content.


Consolidating Family Plans for Software

If you have adult children, utilize family plan consolidation. A Spotify Premium individual account costs roughly fourteen dollars a month. A family plan covering six accounts costs twenty dollars a month. If you are paying for an individual account, your daughter is paying for an individual account, and your son is paying for an individual account, your family is wasting massive amounts of capital. Consolidate everything into a single family plan and split the bill annually. Apply this exact logic to Microsoft 365 and YouTube Premium. Software companies offer bulk discounts. Force your extended family to exploit them.


Buying Refurbished Hardware Without the Risk

You refuse to pay retail prices for a car because a new car loses twenty percent of its value the second the tires hit the street. Technology depreciates twice as fast as an automobile. An iPhone loses thirty percent of its resale value in the first six months. You must stop subsidizing the depreciation curve for the hardware industry. Buy used.


Factory Certified Programs Versus Third-Party Resellers

Buying a used laptop from a random teenager on Facebook Marketplace is a massive risk. The hard drive might fail tomorrow. The device might be stolen. You completely avoid this risk by utilizing official manufacturer refurbished programs. Apple runs a certified refurbished store buried at the bottom of their website. They take a lightly used computer, install a brand new battery, install a brand new outer aluminum shell, package it in a sealed white box, and sell it with the exact same one-year warranty as a new machine. You get a functionally new computer for fifteen percent less than retail. Samsung and Dell operate identical programs. You take zero risk and pocket the cash.


The Mathematical Sweet Spot of One-Generation-Old Tech

The greatest trick the technology industry ever played was convincing the public that a one-year-old device is obsolete. If Apple releases the M3 processor this week, the M2 processor they released last year does not suddenly become slow. It remains blindingly fast. However, retailers panic and slash the prices on the M2 inventory to clear shelf space for the new boxes. This is the mathematical sweet spot. You hunt for brand new, sealed-in-box hardware that belongs to the immediately preceding generation. You buy a highly capable machine at a twenty-five percent discount simply because the number on the box is a digit lower. When you audit your technology replacement budget, build the spreadsheet based strictly on refurbished or last-generation pricing. Let the teenagers pay the early adopter tax.


Personal Reflections on Managing Tech Expenses

I realized the severity of technology inflation during a casual conversation with a retired machinist in Cleveland. He showed me his budget spreadsheet on a massive, heavy Dell laptop from 2014. It took four minutes just to boot up Windows. The fan screamed like a jet engine. He told me he was terrified to replace it because a salesman at a big box store told him a new machine would cost over a thousand dollars, and he needed that money to fix his transmission. He was actively choosing between transportation and computing access because he viewed technology as an insurmountable capital wall.

I sat down with him and ordered a factory-refurbished business laptop for three hundred and fifty dollars. We spent another forty dollars on a solid-state drive. It booted in twelve seconds. He was stunned. He had completely bought into the retail lie that keeping up with modern internet security required a four-figure expenditure every three years. That interaction forced me to look at my own recurring tech costs. I found three different cloud storage subscriptions automatically billing my credit card for services I had not logged into since 2019. I was actively funding Silicon Valley server farms out of pure laziness.

You have to view technology the exact same way you view a refrigerator or a hot water heater. It is a utility appliance. It is not a status symbol. It is not an exciting toy. It is a tool required to navigate a digital society. I completely stopped buying flagship phones. I buy mid-tier devices, put them in heavy rubber cases, and hold them until the software refuses to update. I established a specific sinking fund at an online bank that pulls forty dollars a month out of my checking account. I never think about hardware replacement costs anymore. The money simply sits there, quietly compounding at five percent, waiting for a motherboard to fail. It removes the panic entirely.

Taking control of your retirement budget means hunting down every single leak. A ten-dollar monthly software subscription seems harmless until you multiply it by twenty years and realize you just handed a software developer two thousand dollars of your fixed income. Audit the hardware. Audit the subscriptions. Consolidate the services and stagger the upgrade cycles. Protect your capital with ruthless precision.


Frequently Asked Questions


FAQ 1: How long should a modern smartphone last in retirement?

A modern smartphone should easily last between four and five years for a user not pushing heavy gaming or professional video processing. The key to reaching year five is replacing the lithium-ion battery around year three. The processor and camera remain highly capable; only the chemical battery degrades physically. Manufacturers now provide software security updates for five to seven years, removing the forced obsolescence barrier.


FAQ 2: Are smart home devices worth the continuous replacement costs?

Mathematically, no. Smart home devices introduce rapid depreciation and mandatory subscription fees into systems that previously functioned perfectly for decades. While smart thermostats or doorbell cameras provide convenience, they fail significantly faster than their analog counterparts. Retirees on a strict fixed income should prioritize hardwired, subscription-free security systems and traditional appliances to avoid recurring monthly drains on their cash flow.


FAQ 3: How do I budget for software subscriptions?

Treat software subscriptions exactly like utility bills. List every active subscription—cloud storage, Microsoft Office, streaming services, and password managers—on a master ledger. Calculate the annual total. If you pay fifteen dollars a month for a service, recognize it as a one-hundred-and-eighty-dollar annual liability. Rotate entertainment subscriptions monthly and consolidate cloud storage into family plans to aggressively reduce this total burn rate.


FAQ 4: Should retirees buy extended warranties for laptops?

Extended warranties from big box retailers are notoriously terrible investments. They function as high-margin insurance products that rarely pay out without a fight. Instead of paying two hundred dollars for an extended warranty on an eight-hundred-dollar laptop, put that two hundred dollars directly into your technology sinking fund. Self-insure the hardware. If the laptop breaks, you use your own cash to fix it. If it survives, you keep the cash.


FAQ 5: What is a technology sinking fund?

A sinking fund is a dedicated savings account used to proactively save for predictable future expenses. Because technology failure is inevitable, you calculate the annual replacement cost of all your devices and divide it by twelve. You automatically transfer that specific amount into the sinking fund every month. When a device dies, you pay for the replacement using the accumulated cash in the fund, avoiding credit card debt or liquidating retirement investments.


FAQ 6: Is a desktop cheaper to maintain than a laptop?

Yes. Desktops operate in larger cases with superior airflow, preventing the thermal damage that slowly destroys cramped laptops. They draw power directly from the wall, eliminating the rapid degradation of lithium-ion batteries. Furthermore, desktop components are modular. If a single stick of RAM or a power supply fails, you replace a fifty-dollar part instead of throwing away a thousand-dollar machine. Desktops significantly outlast laptops.


FAQ 7: Do security cameras require mandatory monthly fees?

Consumer brands like Ring, Arlo, and Google Nest heavily push monthly subscriptions to store your video footage in the cloud. If you refuse to pay, the camera often becomes a basic live-view monitor without recording capability. You bypass these fees entirely by installing a Power over Ethernet (PoE) camera system with a local Network Video Recorder (NVR). The footage saves to a physical hard drive inside your house, eliminating cloud subscriptions permanently.


FAQ 8: How much cash should sit in a tech replacement budget?

The total balance should equal the replacement cost of your two most expensive devices. For most retirees, this means keeping enough cash to buy a new smartphone and a new computer simultaneously. If a decent phone costs six hundred dollars and a reliable computer costs eight hundred dollars, your sinking fund should ideally hold fourteen hundred dollars. Once the account hits this cap, you can pause monthly contributions until a purchase depletes the balance.


Legal Disclaimer

The information provided in this article is for general informational and educational purposes only. It does not constitute formal financial, accounting, or professional technical advice. Technology pricing, software subscription models, and manufacturer support timelines change frequently based on market dynamics and corporate policy. The budget strategies and examples provided do not guarantee specific financial outcomes. Always consult with a certified financial planner, a registered investment advisor, or a qualified fiduciary before making significant alterations to your retirement budget, cash flow planning, or asset allocation. The author and publisher assume no responsibility for any financial losses incurred based on the interpretations of the tech replacement strategies discussed herein.

Comments